Posts

The Art of Decision

How many decisions are made during the process of building a home? I don’t have a number but I know it is many. Designing and building Desert Rain, the compound of structures, and mechanical systems and meeting the Living Building Challenge criteria,  stretches those decisions by leaps and bounds. I recently listened in on a design meeting for the proposal of a new structure on the compound. In the three plus years the project has been underway there have been a series of design changes as building for LBC certification has many unknowns and is a ‘learn as we go’ process.

design meeting

Barb, Tom, Al Tozer , and James Fagan take a look at the preliminary design for the new structure, Desert Lookout.

The plan to this point has been to keep the garage from the original structures on the site and remodel it to create Desert Station – a studio space. With the waste water system still pending approval there is the need to build a composting toilet facility. In the usual team effort that keeps Desert Rain evolving, the new concept is to build a structure that will do more of what meets the needs of the project and Barb and Tom’s lifestyle. Al Tozer, designer,  presented the preliminary concept for the new structure – Desert Lookout. Included in the design is a garage, an upstairs unit that could be office or dwelling, a fitness space, and the composting toilet facility. The design is functional, aesthetic, and may have some dramatic elements. The decisions begin.

Interior choices - colors, knobs, tiles, materials- tough decisions.

Interior choices – colors, knobs, tiles, materials- tough decisions.

Considerations in the decision process factor in the cost, time-line, aesthetics, function, materials, and how it can meet the LBC standards. The water petal has been a significant challenge to meet. The permit is still pending for the water system. The city required that the site is hooked to city water and sewer.  Early in the process the decision was made to plumb the structures for both conventional and alternative systems. There has been discussion about hooking the Accessory Dwelling Unit to the sewer.  That would result in losing the LBC Water Petal; Barb and Tom are reluctant to let that happen – a tough decision.  The big choice about Desert Lookout: keep it functional and affordable, sacrifice drama for costs, or make a statement. Tom reminded everyone that, ‘ The whole home is a demonstration project. Every aspect needs to demonstrate something innovative and it also needs to make an aesthetic statement’.  More tough decisions.

Gabriel Dansky with Dansky Handcrafted, Tom and Barb look at the cabinets.

Gabriel Dansky with Dansky Handcrafted, Tom and Barb look at the cabinets and discuss options for the exterior finish.

 

 

 

 

 

As the large decisions loom there are ongoing, daily details that need answers; choosing fixtures, appliances, cabinets, doorknobs, wall textures and colors, how many shelves, art niche or storage cabinet, – the list is long. In addition to making choices every product and material used must be vetted through ML Vidas, a sustainable architect and consultant for Desert Rain and LBC compliance. The spread sheet for that process is growing.

American Clay plaster walls  - Earth, and the custom Manzanita on the Miro wall.

American Clay plaster walls – Earth, and the custom Manzanita on the Miro wall.

While Barb and Tom and the design/build team collaborate on new questions, work continues with the elements that have completed the decision-making and approval process. Inside is seeing more finishes.

 

The American Clay plaster is nearing completion, cabinet bases are being installed, and the reclaimed wood is in place on the ceiling and trim. The exterior of the site is currently under siege as trenches are abundant laying infrastructure for the rainwater catchment, gray-water, and waste-water lines. When the excavation moves out of the courtyard construction on the exterior Miro wall and other landscaping features can begin. The exterior plaster will be applied to the structures, and the old garage will be deconstructed. As many materials as possible from the garage will be reclaimed and used. Jim Fagan, general contractor with Timberline said,’we are wrapping our arms around all these elements, staying within a time-line’.
With so many questions unanswered, options to ponder, choices to make; many of us would simply give up or collapse . Barb and Tom keep forging forward. Continuing to embrace this innovative and conceptual project, Barb stated, ‘this is a learning environment and still very much our passion’. Perhaps in the process of creating Desert Rain, Barb and Tom have learned the ‘art of decision’.

done

One wall, one word, one decision – done.

Teamwork in Every Phase

What goes on behind closed doors …

Mission control at Desert Rain (the garage from the site's former home).

… is a lot of planning! And it most certainly does not stay behind closed doors when it comes to Desert Rain and Living Building Challenge.

Jim Fagan (contractor, Timberline Construction), Al Tozer (architectural designer, Tozer Design) and ML Vidas (LBC/LEED consultant) meet to discuss what's happening, and what's coming up, at Desert Rain.

The day started off with an early morning meeting on the home site for architectural designer Al Tozer, contractor Jim Fagan, and LBC/LEED consultant ML Vidas. They walked the site–which was abuzz with framing activity, as well as masonry and cistern work–as they discussed all aspects of the project. Building a home to meet Living Building Challenge 2.0 is radically different than building a standard home. What’s being done is new; groundbreaking both literally (I’m looking at you, 35,000-gallon cistern) and figuratively. It requires more time, more creativity, and more communication in all aspects. While there is a written standard, there is also a remarkable amount of details that must be dealt with at every step of the process, and for that there is no trail of crumbs to follow. “I have to remind myself and the team that this is all pioneering stuff. … That’s why having the team is so important. Jim and Kevin [of Timberline, or Jim] and I meet almost weekly,” ML told me last month.

Meeting to discuss the monitoring and control of Desert Rain's water and energy systems. April 17, 2012

After the on-site meeting between ML, Al and Jim, there was a meeting at the Timberline office that brought together Barb and Tom, Al, ML, and Jim, as well as Shawn Allen and Greg Anderson of Resource Conservation Technologies. Shawn and Greg are leading the team in the monitoring and control of the water and energy systems that are so vital to Desert Rain achieving net-zero water and net-zero energy. Detailed monitoring of systems is essential to the conservation and efficient use and management of water (rainwater harvesting) and energy (generated via solar panels) in Desert Rain. Real-time analytics will alert Barb and Tom to any energy “leak,” giving them the ability to quickly react and improve efficiency. Even if they’re away from home, they’ll be instantly notified of any inefficiency via a system-generated email or  text, and with remote access they can explore and address the issue from wherever they may be.

More photos from today’s collaboration are below. If you’d like to learn more about Living Building Challenge—the standard that inspired and informs every aspect of this home—please join us on Thursday morning (4/19) at 7:30 for an LBC presentation in Bend. Email me via the “contact” form on the blog and we’ll add your name to the list of attendees.

Tom meets with Desert Rain team members to discuss monitoring and control of the home's water and energy systems.

Barb meets with the Desert Rain team at the Timberline office to discuss the home's sophisticated monitoring and control of energy and water generation and usage.

Shawn Allen of Resource Conservation Technologies.

Greg Anderson of Resource Conservation Technologies.

Discussing energy monitoring in Desert Rain.

April 17, 2012